6 Best Reeses Book Club Picks of 2025 Reviewed
Looking for reeses book club picks? We picked six page-turners from reeses book club on Amazon that will hook any reader.
Finding a great book can feel harder than picking a Reese’s out of one of those snack bags. That’s why we made this list of the 6 best reeses book club picks. We chose our favorites based on stories that kept us up late, characters we wanted to text, and twists that shocked even our most suspicious friend. Whether you like mystery, heart, or just want a book you’ll talk about for weeks, these reeses book club stories have something for everyone.
On this list:
6 Where the Crawdads Sing by Delia Owens
This book is one we couldn’t put down, even though we spilled coffee on it twice. Reese’s Book Club made a great pick here. It’s got mystery, romance, and a marsh so thick you could lose your shoes in it. We chose this because it’s the type of book that gets everyone talking (and crying) at book club.
5 The Guest List by Lucy Foley
We played detective with our friends, and nobody guessed the ending. This Reese’s Book Club pick is a twisty mystery on a creepy island, and it’s one of those ‘just-one-more-chapter-then-oops-I’m-done’ reads. Great for anyone who likes Agatha Christie but with smartphones.
4 Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine by Gail Honeyman
Eleanor made us laugh, cringe, and wish we had her cat. This Reese’s Book Club novel is about friendship, loneliness, and learning how to socialize without turning beet red. We picked it for its humor and heart—it’s like therapy, but cheaper.
3 The Last Thing He Told Me by Laura Dave
If you enjoy secrets, family drama, and people running from the FBI (but who doesn’t?), this Reese’s Book Club selection is for you. We ended up googling ‘can you really disappear this fast?’ afterward. It’s exciting and keeps you on your toes.
2 Little Fires Everywhere by Celeste Ng
Suburban drama at its finest! This Reese’s Book Club pick made us look at our neighbors in a whole new way. It’s full of secrets, but thankfully no actual fires at our weekly meeting. We love it for its slow burn (pun intended).
1 The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah
We saved the best for last! The Nightingale is the book that made us all ugly cry, even our tough friend who claims she never does. Reese’s Book Club nailed it here. This epic story of two sisters in World War II France is full of danger, hope, and those tear-jerking moments that linger with you for days. We chose this as the best because it brings every emotion possible to the table—it’s got love, loss, bravery, and sacrifice. The writing pulls you in and doesn’t let go, and you might even call your sister afterward just to tell her you love her. Basically, if you want a Reese’s Book Club read that hits hard and leaves you thinking about it long after, this is the one.
